Captured in Time and Space vs. Farewell

Mountain Man · Post by **Mountain Man** » Tue Feb 28, 2006 9:42 am

I'm just curious to see what people's opinions are.

yamasaaaki har har · Post by **yamasaaaki har har** » Tue Feb 28, 2006 10:04 am

Hard choice. Captured is loaded with excellent keyboard playing, but I still have to say I prefer Farewell because it's more up-to-date, the song selection covers more albums, and the guitar is louder.

calicowriter · Post by **calicowriter** » Tue Feb 28, 2006 10:06 am

That's kind of not fair. CITAS (or whatever) had a lot more production, a lot more opportunity for picking the right video since it was done over several nights, and a lot more songs.

I have however, voted for Farewell because I was there, because I prefer John's voice to Greg's, and because I prefer the songs on Farewell.

So, for me it is a matter of preference, not necessarily what is "better."

Shell · Post by **Shell** » Tue Feb 28, 2006 11:19 am

I like them both, but I prefer Farewell just because Greg B. and Paul are on it. It is a matter of preference; they're from totally different times in Petra's history.

Petra24 · Post by **Petra24** » Tue Feb 28, 2006 11:33 am

I voted for Farewell but greatly enjoy CITAS. That cassette was one of my first Petra purchases years ago. I really like Bob's solo work on CITAS.

Mountain Man · Post by **Mountain Man** » Tue Feb 28, 2006 1:05 pm

calicowriter wrote:That's kind of not fair. CITAS (or whatever) had a lot more production, a lot more opportunity for picking the right video since it was done over several nights, and a lot more songs.

You just listed off the reasons why I prefer CITAS over Farewell. Farewell is a terrific live album, but CITAS, to me, sounds more energetic and spontaneous. I also prefer the crystal clear mix over Farewell's slightly muffled "live" sound.

That said, CITAS barely, and I mean barely, edges out Farewell in my book.

js3971 · Post by **js3971** » Tue Feb 28, 2006 3:41 pm

It was close, but I went with Farewell. I love Farewell, but as I've said before watching and listening to CIT&S is when I really grew to love Petra and their music.

Petrapraise · Post by **Petrapraise** » Tue Feb 28, 2006 5:45 pm

I was at the Farewell concert, but I'm going with CITAS (went to that concert in JAX). I prefer hearing the whole, full concert. We get to hear all the ministry and stories along with the music. All the music was great from Farewell, but it wasn't like a regular concert.

nyanks15 · Post by **nyanks15** » Tue Feb 28, 2006 8:54 pm

well i didnt go to any of them but my opion is that i like CTAS reason is that i beleive the melody sounds better then Farwell tour..When i first seen Petra was 89 in NY ON FIRE TOUR and they blew me away i was in the front row. with RONNIE AND JOHN LAWREY great voice and i truly beleive they sound so much better then today voices that is just my opion..

[/i][/b]

yamasaaaki har har · Post by **yamasaaaki har har** » Wed Mar 01, 2006 1:36 pm

The "The Race" keyboard solo on CITAS with the bass and drums is probably the best thing I've ever listened to by Petra. It just gets me jumping and dancing, it's so fast and such a musical thriller!!

I think one of the reasons that I overall prefer Farewell slightly more than CITAS is that both John and Greg sing on it. I like both voices but I tend to favor John's. If there was more keyboard on Farewell, though, it would be better.

I really wish Petra released another live album in like 1988-1993 or so. I want to know what they sounded like in concert back then. Are there any audio or video clips available of Petra concerts during that era?

greenchili · Post by **greenchili** » Wed Mar 01, 2006 7:24 pm

I have to go with CITAS simply because it is more complete.

Nothing really cut out, everything is there including the talking, which I usually do not care for, but it is there.

Video has songs not on the CD as well as extended versions (see praise meledy).

Just all around more complete.

Farewell was nice but there was a couple things on it I didn't care for. The DVD does not really include anything new (concert) wise, but it does have a few extra's.

Regardless Farewell is the only thing we have, that I know of, with John live (with the exception of the Creation Fest video floating around on the net). Plus maybe a couple live radio things petra did (pretty wild!).

Mountain Man · Post by **Mountain Man** » Wed Mar 01, 2006 10:03 pm

greenchili wrote:Video has songs not on the CD as well as extended versions (see praise meledy).

One of my favorite Petra moments. I love the way Greg Volz works his way around the stage and gets the crowd motivated.

greenchili · Post by **greenchili** » Thu Mar 02, 2006 12:30 am

Mountain Man wrote:
greenchili wrote:Video has songs not on the CD as well as extended versions (see praise meledy).
One of my favorite Petra moments. I love the way Greg Volz works his way around the stage and gets the crowd motivated.

Yeah it was funny watching Bob run from one side of the stage to the other in order to keep up with him. Greg had alot of energy and in my mind was at his peak when it came to his voice range. Just listen to his voice in the songs and compare them to the studio versions and you will see what I mean.

epdc · Post by **epdc** » Thu Mar 02, 2006 12:01 pm

I prefer farewell because I appear there. HAHAHAHAHA

krazykanuk · Post by **krazykanuk** » Thu Mar 02, 2006 10:11 pm

This is a very tough question because the records are so different. I gave my vote for Farewell because it is harder rocking than Captured and I am impartial to John as a vocalist-I listen to Farewell way more. It is almost a tie though because Captured is the full concert, whereas Farewell is not. I cannot compare the video yet as I don't have the Farewell dvd but I imagine it will be close. Tough call overall.

The Petra Zone

Captured in Time and Space vs. Farewell

Which is the better album?

Captured in Time and Space vs. Farewell

b-b-b-b-boy

ctas vs farwell tour

Time out! Stop this squirrel, and let me get orf

very egocentric HAHAHAHAHAHA

Who is online